sci.energy.hydrogen

"strabo" wrote in message
news:1191551499_7019@ ...
> Richard Macdonald wrote:
>> "strabo" wrote in message
>> news:1191451743_6017@ ...
>>> Richard Macdonald wrote:
>>>> wrote in message
>>>> news: @ ...
>>>>> /articles/october2007/
>
>>>> One key word people forget in the 1st Amendment is "peacable"
>>>> excersing your free speach in a manner to disturb and disrupt others
>>>> activities is not peacable.
>>> So you want to silence some people because what they may say
>>> 'disturbs' your delicate sensibilities, or 'disrupts' your
>>> profound meditation.
>>>
>>> But your 'key word' is out of context...
>>
>> Peacably assembling relates to associated actions not content of speach.
>> Lets satart at the top.
>>
>> Is lighting fires and throwing rocks peacable?
>>
>> Is obstructing access and traffic flow peacable?
>
> 'Peaceably assembling' refers to assembling as a group
> in a lawful manner. It does not refer to speech.
>
> Your words?
> "excersing your free speach in a manner to disturb and disrupt
> others activities is not peacable."

So you believe that shouting loudly all night should be allowed,
I will move in next door whth my Royal Scots Dragoon Guards
tapes on my stereo.

> You conditioned speech with 'peaceable' meaning that you
> believe that if someone speaks in a manner you don't like
> you can accuse them of impinging on your rights.

Speaking, no problem, shouting, loud continoud chanting or
singing, yes problem, volume is the question, not content.

>>> "...or the right of the people peaceably to assemble..."
>>>
>>> ...which leaves open the right to disturb or disrupt within
>>> the framework of conflicting rights.
>>
>> When you actions impinge on others ability to freely act, is your action
>> peacable?
>
> That is my point, and shouting or mudslinging, etc., does not impinge
> upon your rights.

Mudslinging certainly impinges on my property rights and dry cleaning bills.
--
Richard A. Macdonald, CPA/EA
SSG(Ret), USA, ADA, 16P34
Gib mir Schokolade und niemand wird verletzt!!!