sci.energy.hydrogen

Morris Dovey wrote:
> Don Lancaster wrote:
> | Morris Dovey wrote:
> || daestrom wrote:
> ||
> ||| I've often wondered if a hi-frequency component on a DC 'carrier'
> ||| would have a similar affect on electrolysis. By causing H2
> ||| bubbles to be released from the plates more easily it might be
> ||| possible to continuously expose more plate and thus improve the
> ||| efficacy. I know it won't create more H2 per Joule, but it might
> ||| make the process more productive per unit of plate area.
> ||
> || If you have some idea of the frequencies you'd like to try, I'd
> || suggest looking for help from your local amateur radio club.
> ||
> || There're usually a at least a couple of people who can and are
> || willing to help out with this kind of experiment...
> ||
> | The experiment is utterly and totally pointless to anyone with even
> | the faintest clue what thermodynamics and exergy is all about.
> |
> | /glib/
>
> Perhaps we have differing notions of what makes an experiment
> "pointful". I'm inclined to think that an experiment is worth
> performing if it provides insight or understanding that wasn't there
> before.
>
> Belittling someone who lacks your own understanding, but is who is
> nonetheless capable of wondering - and of designing his own experiment
> to satisfy his curiosity seems unworthy of you.
>
> I expected better.
>
> --
> Morris Dovey
> DeSoto Solar
> DeSoto, Iowa USA
> /DeSoto/
>
>

I expected worse.

An hour on the web is worth a month in the lab.

If you do not believe in Faraday, you have to have some credible
justification for that belief. An observable, quantifiable and
unambiguously independently duplicatable unquestionable hard core result.

One that countless tens of thousands of daily repeated experiments do
not overwhemingly fly in the face of. And not one that thermodynamic
fundamentals involving exergy ABSOLUTELY GUARANTEE ain't gonna happen.

And one that goes beyond obvious incompetence and instruments that
clearly lie like a rug. While making the same stupid mistakes that
everybody else does.

The point is that if they refuse to admit they don't even have the
necessary background and tools, and refuse to try and prove themselves
wrong, and refuse to ask for help, nothing whatsoever is accomplished.

If anything, it self-perpetuates.

Thermodynamic fundamentals ABSOLUTELY GUARANTEE the Meyer experiment is
(A) Not even wrong, and (B) not remotely worth pissing over.

/glib/ and
/glib/ and
/glib/ for tutorials.







--
Many thanks,

Don Lancaster voice phone: (928)428-4073
Synergetics 3860 West First Street Box 809 Thatcher, AZ 85552
rss: / email: don@

Please visit my GURU's LAIR web site at